Casey's Rewards FAQ:
Box Tops

Yes! Pizza box tops aren't going anywhere, but they will be changing. Starting December 1, 2019, you can earn digital pizza box tops with Casey's Rewards. The pizza box tops program will be transitioned in January 2020 from the physical redemption of cardboard box tops to a digital offering as part of Casey's Rewards.

Starting January 1, 2020, you can bring your cardboard box tops into any Casey's store to have them loaded into your Casey's Rewards account by a Casey's team member at the register. All cardboard box tops must be redeemed for a free large pizza or loaded into a Casey's Rewards account before June 30, 2020.

After June 30, 2020, physical box tops can no longer be redeemed as part of Casey's pizza box top program. Any existing physical box tops you have must be brought to a Casey's store location prior to June 30, 2020, and converted to digital.

The box top program will be converted to an entirely digital program. As such, you will need a Casey's account to continue participating in the program.

Earn one box top for every large pizza purchased with your Casey's Rewards account - online, in-store, or over the phone.

Earn a free pizza with the purchase of ten large pizzas (whether by conversion or new purchases). Free pizza offers will be available in your saved offers, and will be applied on your next eligible purchase. All free pizza offers must be redeemed within 60 days. Redemption of the free pizza offer will occur automatically and will apply to the highest-value item (up to $15.99).

You must redeem the free pizza within 60 days or the offer will expire and can no longer be used.

We heard from our guests that we needed an easier way for them to keep track of their hard-earned box tops. We always want our guests to have the best experience possible, so that's why we're transitioning to a digital program where we do the hard work of tracking pizza box tops for you. Those cardboard box tops can easily be lost in the kitchen drawer (we know, we've been there!), and having our digital system in place means you'll never lose a box top again.

You don't need a smartphone to earn pizza box tops. You just need to set up your Casey's Rewards account. This can be done on the Casey's website or in our app. When you are signed into your Casey's account online - or you've given us your phone number when you call - your pizza box tops will automatically be credited to your account when you place your order.

Great news! Casey's loves to support our communities, and that's why giving back is a key feature of Casey's Rewards. Guests will be able to donate the points they earn on every Casey's purchase to their local schools as a cash donation with Cash for Classrooms.

No. We don't expect our guests to eat 10 pizzas in 60 days to earn a free pizza. You can take however long you need to collect 10 pizza box tops with your Casey's account. But once you do get 10, you will get a free large pizza added to your account. Then after you've earned that free pizza, you will have 60 days to use it. When you place your next order, we'll automatically apply the free pizza offer to the highest-priced qualifying pizza.